JJ Ben-JosephModern drivers rely on a variety of services when cars break down: towing, battery jumps, fuel delivery, or lockout help. Companies offer roadside assistance memberships promising peace of mind for a fixed annual fee, often including a limited number of free tows. Without a membership, each tow or service call must be paid out of pocket and prices can fluctuate based on distance or provider. While membership plans sound convenient, they may be unnecessary for drivers with reliable vehicles who rarely need assistance. This calculator helps you determine whether the subscription fee is justified by comparing the annual cost of membership against the expected pay-per-tow expense. It introduces transparency into a decision frequently made based on fear or marketing rather than data.
The tool is useful for everyday drivers, fleet managers, and even ride-share operators who want to optimize maintenance budgets. Small businesses often consider roadside assistance for delivery vans or service vehicles, but usage rates vary. By estimating the number of anticipated service calls, you can see whether a membership saves money or if paying only when needed is better. Because all calculations happen locally in your browser, no personal information is transmitted.
Membership cost is modeled as the annual fee plus the cost of any tows beyond the included amount. If you expect fewer breakdowns than the included number, the membership cost remains the flat fee. For pay-per-tow, the cost is simply the per-tow price multiplied by the expected number of tows. The break-even number of tows B—the point where membership and pay-per-tow cost the same—is calculated assuming no extra tow cost within the included amount. When extra tows have a different price, the formula adjusts accordingly. The general equation for break-even tows is:
where F is the annual fee, P is the pay-per-tow price, E is the extra tow cost under the membership, and I is the number of included tows. If P equals E, the equation reduces to F/P. If the denominator is zero or negative, membership never pays off because extra tows are as expensive as or more expensive than paying outright.
Imagine a roadside club charges $90 per year and includes four free tows. Additional tows cost $40 each. Without membership, a typical tow costs $120. Using the formula, the break-even number of tows is 90/(120 - 40) + 4 = 90/80 + 4 ≈ 5.1 tows. If you anticipate six breakdowns in a year, membership is cheaper. If you expect only one or two incidents, paying per tow will cost less. For annual cost comparison, assume you expect three tows. The membership cost would be $90 (since it covers up to four tows), while paying individually would cost 3×$120 = $360. In this case the membership easily wins. If you expected eight tows, membership would cost $90 + (8 - 4)×40 = $250, while paying each time would cost 8×120 = $960. The savings grow with more incidents, but if you expect zero tows, you would spend $90 unnecessarily.
The table below illustrates the total cost for the example above across several expected tow counts.
| Tows/yr | Membership Cost ($) | Pay-Per-Tow Cost ($) |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | $90 | $240 |
| 5 | $130 | $600 |
| 8 | $250 | $960 |
As the number of tows increases, the membership cost rises slowly after the included four tows, while the pay-per-tow approach grows linearly. The break-even point at just over five tows is evident: beyond that, membership offers substantial savings.
The calculator assumes each tow has the same cost regardless of distance or time of day, which may not hold true in every region. Some membership plans also include benefits like battery jumps or fuel delivery that are not explicitly modeled. If you routinely need non-tow services, include their equivalent pay-per-use cost in the pay-per-tow field to approximate the comparison. The tool also presumes you cannot transfer unused included tows to the following year. For multi-vehicle households, some memberships cover all drivers, while others require separate plans—adjust the fee accordingly.
Another limitation is that the calculation ignores potential inconvenience. Waiting for reimbursement after a pay-per-tow incident or dealing with unfamiliar towing companies may carry a hassle cost. Conversely, membership plans may restrict which providers you can call or limit the distance of free tows, leading to out-of-pocket expenses. Consider these policy details when entering costs.
Despite these caveats, the tool provides a grounded financial lens. Drivers can explore best- and worst-case scenarios by entering zero, average, or high breakdown counts. By comparing with the Car Wash Membership Break-Even Calculator or the Car Repair vs Replacement Cost Calculator, you can develop a broader view of vehicle-related spending and risk management.
Roadside assistance decisions often hinge on personal risk tolerance. Frequent travelers or people with older cars may value the guaranteed support even if costs are marginally higher. Those with new vehicles under warranty might prefer to save the fee. This calculator allows both types of drivers to quantify their choices. By adjusting the expected number of tows, you can also evaluate how maintenance or driving habits affect the need for assistance.
Finally, remember that peace of mind has value beyond dollars. Even if the membership is slightly more expensive, the convenience of a single phone number during stressful breakdowns might be worth it. Use the results as one factor among many, and revisit the calculation yearly as vehicle reliability, driving routes, or membership terms change.
Compare the cost of an annual shipping membership with paying per-order fees to find the break-even number of purchases.
Find out how many units you need to sell to break even. Enter your fixed costs, price per unit, and variable cost per unit to calculate the break-even point.
Estimate whether an electric vehicle charging network membership saves money compared with paying per kWh.