Skilled immigration has become increasingly structured through points-based systems in many countries. These systems assess potential immigrants against specific criteria – like age, education, work experience, language, and job offers – to determine eligibility for work visas or permanent residency. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore how points-based immigration works in Canada, Australia, Singapore, the United Kingdom (UK), New Zealand, and Germany. We’ll cover each country’s system overview, the latest 2025 updates and trends, in-demand occupations, eligibility criteria (and recent changes), and a brief application process overview. Finally, we compare these systems – highlighting similarities, differences, pros, and cons – and provide a summary table for easy reference.
Overview: Canada uses the Express Entry system for economic immigration streams, primarily the Federal Skilled Worker (FSW), Canadian Experience Class, and Federal Skilled Trades programs. It’s a two-stage points system: first, FSW candidates must score at least 67 points out of 100 on six selection factors (age, education, language ability in English/French, work experience, arranged employment, and adaptability) (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com) (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). Eligible candidates then enter the Express Entry pool, where they are ranked by the Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS), a merit-based scoring (out of 1200) that heavily weights age, education, skilled work experience, language proficiency, and other factors like Canadian credentials or a valid job offer. Approximately every two weeks, the government conducts draws inviting top-ranked candidates to apply for permanent residence (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). This competitive points draw means there is no fixed pass mark for CRS – the cut-off score varies by draw based on supply and demand of candidates (recent cut-offs often hover in the high 400s). Candidates without job offers or Canadian experience can still be invited if their human capital scores are high.
2025 Updates & Trends: Canada made sweeping changes in 2023-2024 that carry into 2025. Notably, Express Entry’s share of immigration is increasing – the 2025 target for federal high-skilled admissions (through Express Entry) is 124,590, up from 110,770 in 2024 (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). This comes as Canada reduced some other categories (like provincial nominations), meaning Express Entry will play a more dominant role in selecting newcomers (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). A major policy change is the removal of CRS points for job offers (arranged employment) starting in spring 2025 (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). Previously, having a job offer could add 50 or 200 CRS points (for non-managerial vs. executive roles), often giving those candidates a significant advantage. Immigration Minister Marc Miller announced that for now these additional points will be zeroed out as a “temporary measure” (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). This levels the playing field and shifts focus back to core human capital factors; however, it’s uncertain how it will affect cut-off scores or invite trends (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News).
Another big development is category-based selections in Express Entry. Starting in 2023, Canada began holding targeted draws for candidates with specific attributes (like work experience in certain fields or strong French language skills) to better meet labor market needs (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). In 2025 this continues under a new allocation framework: “Federal Economic Priorities” draws will target key sectors, while “In-Canada Focus” draws prioritize candidates already in Canada (such as international students or workers) (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). Priority categories in 2025 include healthcare occupations, trades, and French-language proficiency (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News) (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). We expect more occupation-specific draws for healthcare workers (doctors, nurses, medical technicians) and skilled trades (carpenters, plumbers, electricians, etc.), as these were designated priority areas, alongside ongoing draws to boost francophone immigration (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). In contrast, general all-program draws may become less frequent or have higher cut-offs as the government balances these targeted invitations. Overall, Canada’s trend is toward a more directed selection of skilled immigrants to address shortages (e.g. the healthcare backlog) and regional needs, within its high immigration targets.
Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: Canada’s labor market in 2025 strongly demands professionals in healthcare, technology, skilled trades, and francophone talent. The Express Entry category-based draws underscore this: healthcare roles (such as registered nurses, physicians, pharmacists) and trade occupations (industrial electricians, welders, contractors, etc.) are explicitly prioritized (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). Additionally, French-speaking candidates receive attention, reflecting Canada’s goal to attract francophone immigrants outside Quebec (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). Beyond those categories, tech and IT professionals remain in demand (often picked up through provincial programs or previous STEM draws), as do engineers, financial services professionals, and other STEM fields – though “STEM” per se isn’t named as a 2025 category, Canada continues to welcome many in these fields via either federal or provincial streams. The Provincial Nominee Programs (PNPs) also contribute by nominating candidates in occupations like truck drivers, software developers, early childhood educators, and other region-specific shortages. In summary, healthcare and tech are “hot” sectors, and Canada is also keen on skilled tradespeople to support infrastructure and housing development (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News).
Eligibility Criteria & Recent Changes: To immigrate under FSW (the main route for those without Canadian experience), applicants must have at least one year of continuous full-time skilled work experience, a minimum language level of Canadian Language Benchmark CLB 7 in English or French, and an education credential assessment if their degree is foreign (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). They also need to score 67/100 on the FSW points grid as noted earlier (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). Key factors on that grid include age (maximum points if 18-35 years), education level (more points for post-graduate degrees), work experience duration, language test scores, and adaptability factors (such as previous study/work in Canada or having relatives in Canada) (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com) (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com).
Notable changes affecting eligibility in the past couple of years include the adoption of the new TEER occupational classification (replacing the old NOC “Skill Level” system) – now all occupations at TEER 0, 1, 2, or 3 are eligible for Express Entry (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). This change (implemented late 2022) actually expanded eligibility to some occupations that were previously considered lower skill (for example, transport truck drivers and hospital orderlies became eligible under TEER 3). Another change was increasing points for French proficiency: a strong French score can add 25–50 extra CRS points as of 2022, an incentive for bilingual applicants (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News). On the flip side, as mentioned, points for a job offer will be temporarily zero in 2025 (These are the changes coming to Express Entry in 2025 | CIC News), meaning foreign workers can’t rely on arranged employment for a CRS boost (though having a job can still help meet the FSW baseline via the adaptability factor). Settlement funds criteria remain in place (unless you have a valid job offer, you must show a certain amount of savings) (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). Otherwise, core criteria (age max 46 for CRS points, etc.) remain unchanged. Canada sets no formal age limit, but in practice candidates older than 45 have difficulty scoring enough points due to age point drop-off. Overall, Canada’s system rewards younger, highly educated, and fluent English/French-speaking applicants with skilled experience, and recent tweaks have further emphasized language and in-demand skills.
Application Process Overview: Canada’s Express Entry process is online and streamlined, typically taking about 6 months for processing after you’re invited and submit your final application (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). The steps are:
Prepare documents and take tests: Applicants need results of an approved language test (IELTS or CELPIP for English, TEF/TCF for French) and an Educational Credential Assessment (ECA) for foreign degrees. You should also gather reference letters for work experience and ensure you meet FSW 67-point criteria (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com).
Create an Express Entry profile: You fill in your personal information, work history, education, language scores, etc., on IRCC’s online portal. The system assigns you a CRS score based on your profile. Your profile enters the pool of candidates and is valid for up to 12 months.
Wait for an Invitation to Apply (ITA): Periodically, IRCC conducts draws. If your CRS score is at or above the draw’s cut-off (or if you fall in a targeted category draw), you receive an ITA for permanent residency (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). For example, IRCC often invites a few thousand candidates in a draw, and you must be among the top-ranked to get an ITA.
Submit PR application: Once invited, you have 60 days to submit a complete application for permanent residence, including uploading documents (police certificates, medical exam results, proof of funds, work reference letters, etc.) and paying fees. The application is then processed by an immigration officer.
Receive a decision and immigrate: IRCC aims to process most Express Entry PR applications in 6 months or less (FSWP: Immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program | Canadavisa.com). If approved, you’ll get a Confirmation of Permanent Residence (COPR) and can then move to Canada and complete landing formalities. As a permanent resident, you have the right to live and work anywhere in Canada.
Costs: The process involves an application fee (currently about CAD $1,365 for the principal applicant, plus a ~$515 right of permanent residence fee upon approval, and additional fees for any spouse or dependents). Including medical exams, credential assessments, and other miscellaneous costs, a single applicant can expect to spend roughly CAD $2,000 in government fees. There is no fee to create an Express Entry profile, but fees are paid when submitting the final PR application.
Canada’s Express Entry remains a gold-standard for points-based immigration – it’s transparent, fast, and allows direct permanent residency. The 2025 changes are making it even more targeted toward the country’s economic needs while keeping the fundamental points meritocracy intact.
Overview: Australia’s skilled immigration operates on a points test for several visa subclasses, notably the Skilled Independent (subclass 189), Skilled Nominated (190), and Skilled Work Regional (491) visas. The system assesses factors such as age, English language ability, skilled work experience (in Australia or overseas), education qualifications, and other criteria (like Australian study, regional study, specialist education, spouse skills, etc.). Applicants must score at least 65 points to be eligible to lodge an Expression of Interest (EOI) (SkillSelect Visa Points Test Calculator 2025 - Anzscosearch). This 65-point pass mark is a baseline; however, invitation rounds are competitive – in practice, a much higher score may be needed to actually receive an invitation for a visa, especially in popular occupations.
Australia uses an EOI pool (SkillSelect) similar to Canada’s pool system. Once an applicant submits an EOI with their points score, they enter the pool for consideration. The government (and state/territory governments for nominated visas) issue invitations to apply to the highest scoring candidates in each occupation or visa category during periodic invitation rounds. Thus, while 65 is the minimum, candidates with 80+ points often have a significantly better chance, and some occupations facing quota limits (e.g. accountants or certain engineers) might effectively require even higher scores (in recent rounds, some pro-rata occupations only got invites at 95+ points, reflecting high competition) (AUSTRALIA - Impact of the 2024-2025 Federal Budget on Migration …). The points factors are straightforward: for example, age 25–32 gives the maximum 30 points, “Superior” English (IELTS 8.0 or equivalent) gives 20 points, a PhD earns 20 points, 8–10 years of skilled work abroad gives 15 points (additional points if that work was in Australia), etc. (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). No job offer is required for these independent skilled visas – points are king. Australia also has an occupation list requirement: your occupation must be on the relevant skilled occupation list and you generally need a positive skills assessment in that occupation to qualify.
2025 Updates & Trends: Australia is undergoing a significant migration program reform starting 2024, which impacts the points-based system in 2025 (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP) (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP). The government conducted a comprehensive review of the migration system and as a result announced plans to revamp the skilled migration points test to better target economic needs. In 2024, a “new point test system” was introduced in principle, emphasizing factors like education, English proficiency, occupation and age – replacing or reducing emphasis on some older points factors that were seen as less tied to long-term economic contribution (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). In short, highly educated and younger applicants stand to benefit, while points for things like a spouse’s qualifications or having studied in Australia may be adjusted. These changes aim to ensure the points system selects immigrants who will boost productivity and fill genuine skill gaps (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP).
Another major change is the consolidation of occupation lists. In December 2024, Australia introduced a Core Skills Occupation List (CSOL) – a single, curated list of 456 in-demand occupations that replaces previous multiple skilled occupation lists (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). This unified list, developed by Jobs and Skills Australia, is meant to be more responsive and aligned with actual labor market needs, simplifying the system. Practically, this means the vast majority of skilled jobs (456 occupations is quite comprehensive) are eligible for sponsorship or skilled migration, but the focus is on those that truly address Australia’s skill shortages (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025).
In terms of visa pathways, Australia has also introduced new avenues: as of December 2024, the Temporary Skill Shortage (TSS) work visa (subclass 482) was replaced by a new “Skills in Demand” visa (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP) (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). This is an employer-sponsored route with three streams, designed to fill immediate shortages more flexibly (including a pathway for roles earning above certain salary thresholds). While the employer-sponsored route is separate from the independent points test, it shows Australia’s broader trend of focusing on critical skills. The government also announced a forthcoming “High Potential / Innovation visa” to attract global talent in research, tech, and creative industries by invitation (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP).
Importantly, the allocation of skilled visa places in the Migration Program has shifted: for the 2024–25 year, Australia lowered the planned intake for Skilled Independent visas to 16,900, almost half of the previous year’s 30,000+ (From skilled visas to ballots: How Australia’s migration changes could unfold in 2025 | SBS News). This indicates fewer spots for independent migrants, making the points competition fiercer. Meanwhile, slightly more spots were given to employer-sponsored and global talent routes (From skilled visas to ballots: How Australia’s migration changes could unfold in 2025 | SBS News). This trend might continue, meaning high-scoring candidates or those nominated by states (who can get an extra 5 or 15 points for nomination) have an edge.
In summary, 2025 will see a transition: Australia’s points system is being fine-tuned for quality over quantity. We expect the government to consult and implement a reformed points test that rewards younger, highly skilled migrants ready to drive economic growth (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP). Potential applicants should watch for updated points tables and be prepared for possibly higher English or salary benchmarks. Despite reforms, Australia remains keen to attract skilled migrants in key industries, but it is making the pathway more strategic and aligned with labor market demand.
Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: Australia’s skill shortages span a variety of sectors, and the policy changes reflect those needs. According to government skill priority lists, some of the most in-demand occupations include: Healthcare professionals (doctors, nurses, aged care and disability support workers), ICT and technology specialists (software engineers, ICT security specialists, data scientists), Engineers (civil, mechanical, electrical, mining engineers), Construction trades (carpenters, electricians, plumbers, welders – especially with major infrastructure projects ongoing), and Teachers (especially in regional areas). The new Core Skills Occupation List covers a broad range of occupations, from accountants and auditors to architects, scientists, veterinarians, and multimedia specialists (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). This indicates Australia is casting a wide net for talent. However, certain sectors are persistently short-staffed:
Healthcare: Australia’s aging population and pandemic aftermath cause high demand for nurses, general practitioners, physiotherapists, and other medical technicians. Nurses in particular are on nearly every state’s priority list.
STEM and ICT: Roles like software developer, ICT security specialist, and system analyst are needed for Australia’s growing tech scene. The government has even created dedicated programs (Global Talent Visa) for ultra-high-skilled tech individuals in AI, fintech, etc., underscoring demand.
Engineering and Construction: With numerous infrastructure projects and a housing construction push, civil and structural engineers, project managers, and skilled trades in construction are sought after. Mining engineers and geologists also remain in need in the resources sector.
Education: School teachers (especially math/science teachers) and early childhood educators are in shortage in various regions.
Finance and Business: Accountants and auditors frequently appear in skilled visa occupation ceilings (often with pro-rated invite quotas due to high volume of applicants), indicating demand remains steady.
Australia also identifies emerging sectors (e.g. the “Green Economy” – renewable energy specialists, climate scientists) and regional needs (agriculture, veterinary, etc.). The Skills Priority List 2023 by the National Skills Commission showed shortages in 42% of assessed occupations, with acute shortfalls in health, tech, engineering, and the trades. The new policies like the CSOL aim to ensure all these needed roles are accessible via migration. In practice, if you are in a profession like registered nurse, software engineer, aged care manager, construction project manager, chef, or electrician, your skills are highly valued in Australia’s immigration selection.
Eligibility Criteria & Notable Changes: To apply for an Australian points-tested skilled visa, you must meet several baseline criteria in addition to scoring 65+ points:
Age: You must be under 45 years old at the time of invitation to apply. (This is a hard cutoff – if you turn 45 before getting an invite, you become ineligible, although some employer sponsored routes allow older applicants under certain conditions.)
English Language: You need at least Competent English, which is IELTS 6.0 (or equivalent test scores) in each band. Competent English gives 0 points on the test (it’s just the minimum). Higher proficiency yields points: Proficient English (IELTS 7.0) gives +10 points, and Superior English (IELTS 8.0 or above) gives +20 points on the scale (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). English ability is crucial – many applicants take language exams multiple times to boost their score.
Skilled Occupation & Skills Assessment: Your occupation must be on the official skilled occupation list (now the Core Skills List). You must obtain a skills assessment from the designated authority for your occupation, proving your qualifications and experience meet Australian standards. For instance, engineers get assessed by Engineers Australia, accountants by CPA/CAANZ, IT professionals by ACS, etc. Without a positive skills assessment, you cannot claim that occupation or apply.
Qualifications and Work Experience: You should have a reasonably good mix of education and experience to score enough points. A Bachelor’s degree (or higher) from a recognized institution is typically needed to meet skill level requirements (and scores 15 points for a Bachelor’s, 20 for a Master’s/PhD). Work experience in your skilled occupation (at least 3 years for any significant points) greatly boosts your score. Notably, Australia differentiates between overseas work experience (up to 15 points for 8+ years) and Australian work experience (up to 20 points for 8+ years in Australia). This can disadvantage foreign applicants without any Australian work/study, but many still qualify on overseas points alone if they have enough years of experience and perhaps spousal points.
Other Factors: Australia grants bonus points for certain credentials, though these are under review. Examples include: Professional Year in Australia (+5), credentialed community language skills (+5), study in regional Australia (+5), having a skilled spouse or de facto partner who also meets criteria (+5 or +10), or being single (+10, a points advantage introduced in late 2019 to balance family status). These bonus factors can make a difference for borderline cases. In 2024, the review hinted some of these may be reweighted or removed if not aligned to long-term outcomes (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP) – e.g., there’s discussion about reducing points for the spouse factor and rewarding primary applicants more.
Recent changes: The biggest “hard” change recently was the increase of the Temporary Skilled Migration Income Threshold (TSMIT) to AUD $70,000 in 2023, but that affects employer-sponsored visas more than the independent points test. For points-test applicants, no major changes to the points criteria have yet been implemented apart from the 2019 adjustment (which added points for being single or having a skilled spouse). The announced reforms for 2025 may adjust point allocations, but as of early 2025 the 65-point framework still uses the existing points table. One expected change is a more dynamic link between points and salary or skill level; the government has floated ideas like giving substantial points to very high salary earners or those with STEM PhDs, etc., to attract top talent. We will likely see consultations in 2025 to finalize a new points formula (Australia: Migration Strategy Commits to Simplifying Immigration System and Creating New Visa for Skills Shortages | Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP).
It’s also worth noting that state/territory nomination criteria have evolved. If you go for a subclass 190 (state nominated PR) or 491 (regional nominated provisional visa), each state has its own list of in-demand occupations and maybe additional requirements (like job offers or minimum work experience in that state). State nomination gives you 5 points (190) or 15 points (491) on top of your own score, effectively lowering the score you personally need. Many candidates in 2024–25 are securing nominations to ensure an invitation, as the federal independent 189 route has fewer slots. States have become more selective post-pandemic, targeting those already in the state or those offshore in critical sectors.
Application Process Overview: The skilled migration process in Australia involves multiple steps and can take several months (sometimes over a year) from start to finish:
Skill Assessment: Before anything, you must get your skills assessed by the relevant authority for your occupation. This usually requires submitting your educational documents, proof of work experience, and sometimes an English test or other proofs, and paying a fee. Processing times vary (some take a few weeks, others a few months).
Expression of Interest (EOI): Once you have a positive skills assessment and IELTS/PTE English test results, you lodge an EOI in SkillSelect online. In the EOI, you claim your points (which must be calculable and evidenced). You also select which visa(s) and which state nominations you want to be considered for. The EOI will rank you based on your points.
Wait for Invitation: EOIs sit in the pool until an invitation round. The Department of Home Affairs conducts federal invitation rounds for subclass 189 and some 491 Family-sponsored visas. Separately, each state periodically selects EOIs for nomination (for 190/491). This waiting period is variable – some applicants get invited within weeks if they have high points in a high-need occupation; others wait many months. The invitation is the biggest uncertainty because it depends on occupational ceilings and point rankings. (As of 2024–25, federal invitation rounds have become less frequent and smaller in number, due to reduced quota, so many people pursue state nomination for better odds.)
Apply for the Visa: If you receive an Invitation to Apply (ITA) (or a state nomination followed by an ITA), you then have 60 days to lodge your visa application online via ImmiAccount (Top 7 Upcoming Visa Changes in Australia for 2025). This is where you submit all supporting documents: identity docs, skills assessment, language test, work reference letters, education certificates, spouse documents if claiming points, police clearances, health exams, etc. You also pay the visa application fee at this stage (on the order of AUD ~$4,000 for the main applicant, plus additional for any dependants).
Visa Processing: An immigration case officer will assess your application. They verify your points claims against the evidence. If anything is lacking or needs clarification, they might request further info. Processing times for skilled visas can range widely – a typical range is 3 to 9 months after application. Factors include security checks and caseload. (In late 2022, Australia cleared a backlog and many waited over a year; by 2024 processing for straightforward cases improved). If all goes well, you receive a grant of the visa, which for 189/190 is a permanent residency, and for 491 is a 5-year provisional visa leading to PR later. Once granted, you usually must make your initial entry to Australia by a specified date.
Arrival and Settlement: As a permanent resident (189 or 190 visa), you can live and work anywhere in Australia (though 190 nominees are morally expected to spend at least 2 years in the nominating state). PR comes with healthcare access (Medicare) and eventually the option to apply for citizenship after 4 years. If on a 491 visa, you must live/work in a regional area and after 3 years can convert to PR.
Throughout the process, being meticulous with paperwork is key because Australia’s system verifies each point you claim (for instance, claiming points for 5 years of work means you must provide detailed evidence for those 5 years). Also note that costs include not just the visa fee but also medical exam fees, police checks, translation costs, and agent fees if you use a migration agent. The visa fee for a primary applicant is about AUD $4,640 as of 2024 (with additional ~$2,320 for a spouse and ~$1,160 per child) (How much does it cost to get a skilled 189 Australian visa? - Quora), making it a significant investment.
Australia’s points-based system is known for its clarity and strictness – you know exactly how many points you have, but you must hit the threshold and hope it’s high enough for an invitation. In 2025 and beyond, Australia is steering this system to be even more responsive to economic priorities, possibly introducing faster pathways for top talent while maintaining the fundamental points mechanism for general skilled migration.
Overview: The UK implemented a new points-based immigration system in 2021 after Brexit, which applies to both EU and non-EU immigrants alike. The flagship route for skilled workers is the Skilled Worker Visa, which replaced the old Tier 2 (General) work visa. Under this system, applicants must accumulate 70 points to be eligible for a Skilled Worker visa (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris). However, unlike Canada/Australia, these points aren’t gained through an open pool competition but rather function more like a checklist: 50 points are mandatory for having a qualifying job offer by an approved sponsor, a job at the appropriate skill level, and English proficiency, and the remaining 20 points are “tradeable” based on salary, occupation, or other attributes (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris).
In practice, if you have a job offer from a licensed UK employer for a job at or above the required skill level (RQF Level 3, roughly A-level equivalent) and you speak English at B1 level, you’ve secured 50 points. The additional 20 points typically come from the salary: meeting the general salary threshold (usually £26,200/year or the “going rate” for the occupation, whichever is higher) gives 20 points (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris). There are scenarios to trade points – for instance, if the salary is slightly lower (minimum £20,960), you can still get the 20 points if the job is on the Shortage Occupation List or if you have a relevant PhD. But in most cases, employers ensure the salary meets the required level. So effectively, the UK system is job-offer-driven: if an employer is offering you a suitable job and salary and sponsors you, you automatically fulfill the 70 points (50 from job+English, 20 from salary) (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris).
Other routes like the Global Talent Visa or High Potential Individual visa use different criteria (and points in a more discretionary way for Global Talent), but for skilled workers the above is the standard. There is no overarching pool or quota for Skilled Worker visas – anyone who meets the criteria can get one. This marks a shift from the pre-2021 system which had an annual cap (now removed) and required employers to conduct resident labor market tests (also largely removed). The UK’s points system thus prioritizes skills and salary over nationality, treating EU and non-EU equally (The UK’s points-based immigration system: information for EU citizens).
2025 Updates & Trends: In 2025, the UK continues to fine-tune its immigration rules, though not with as radical changes as seen in Canada or Australia. The focus has been on tightening certain aspects to address domestic concerns like abuse of the system and reliance on foreign labor in sensitive sectors, as well as implementing planned post-Brexit adjustments:
Salary Threshold Updates: The salary requirements for Skilled Worker visas are updated periodically. As of April 2023, the general salary threshold was raised (to around £26,200 from £25,600), and many occupation-specific “going rates” (the average salary for each job code) were increased to reflect wage inflation. In April 2025, further adjustments were made especially for the health and education sectors: for example, the minimum salary for Health and Care Worker visas was increased to £25,000 (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). This change was aimed at ensuring migrant healthcare workers are paid at least in line with new pay scales and to discourage undercutting. However, it also means some entry-level healthcare roles (like certain junior care assistants at Band 3) no longer meet the threshold (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025), potentially limiting sponsorship of those roles.
Care Sector Restrictions: A notable rule from April 2025 is that care providers in England must first try to recruit domestically before hiring from abroad. Specifically, before sponsoring care workers from overseas, employers must obtain confirmation from a regional partnership that they attempted to recruit from the resident workforce (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). This is effectively a targeted reintroduction of a labor market test for the care sector, responding to political pressure about over-reliance on migrant care staff. This doesn’t eliminate the care worker route (which was added to the Shortage List in 2022), but adds a hurdle.
Sponsor Compliance and Costs: The UK Home Office is increasingly strict on sponsor compliance. In 2024, the number of sponsor license revocations spiked (513 licenses revoked by Q3 2024, exceeding all of 2023) (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). This trend continues into 2025 with more compliance audits and penalties, signaling to businesses that sponsoring foreign workers is a “privilege to be earned, not a right” (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). Additionally, effective end of 2024, sponsors are prohibited from passing sponsorship costs to the migrant (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). This means an employer cannot charge the sponsored worker for the certificate of sponsorship or immigration skills charge – a move to prevent exploitation and debt bondage. For migrants, this is a positive change (reducing instances where workers had to pay huge fees to agents/employers for sponsorship).
Immigration Fees: The UK significantly increased visa fees and the Immigration Health Surcharge (IHS) in late 2023 and into 2024. For instance, the Skilled Worker visa application fee for a 3+ year visa rose to £1,519 (from around £1,235 previously) (Skilled Worker visa: How much it costs - GOV.UK), and the IHS is slated to rise to £1,035 per year (from £624) soon. By 2025, a 5-year skilled visa for one person can cost well over £5,000 in fees and health surcharge. This hasn’t changed the points criteria, but it’s a trend to note as it increases the cost barrier.
Broader Policy Directions: The UK government is expected to release a White Paper on immigration in 2025 outlining future changes (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025). There is political debate around whether the Skilled Worker route should be tightened further (e.g., raising salary thresholds more, limiting dependants, etc.) or whether shortages necessitate keeping it flexible. So far, no dramatic restrictions have been placed on the main skilled route, but sectors like hospitality and retail remain excluded (no general work visa for lower-skilled jobs). One new route in 2022, the Scale-up Visa, allows sponsored workers to later switch to an unsponsored status, pointing toward future innovation in the system to attract high-growth company talent – but uptake of that has been moderate. In essence, the system in 2025 is stable with incremental adjustments.
The UK’s points system has also introduced routes like the Global Business Mobility visas and rebranded others (High Potential, etc.), forming a whole ecosystem. Yet the Skilled Worker remains the core workhorse for employers bringing talent.
Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: The UK’s Shortage Occupation List and visa statistics give insight into which jobs are being filled by migrants. Key sectors include:
Healthcare: The UK’s National Health Service (NHS) heavily recruits from abroad. Nurses, doctors (especially in general practice), senior care workers, radiographers, and psychologists are in high demand. The Health and Care Worker Visa (a subcategory of Skilled Worker with fee discounts) has made it easier to recruit healthcare professionals quickly. Shortage roles like nurses and senior care assistants have lower salary thresholds (£20,960) (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025) and thousands of visas are granted in these occupations annually.
Information Technology: There is demand for software developers, programmers, cybersecurity specialists, and IT business analysts. While these tech occupations aren’t on the official shortage list, the digital sector is growing and sponsors many workers, especially from countries like India. The Global Talent visa also targets tech (via Tech Nation endorsement, though that program’s future is uncertain after Tech Nation’s closure in 2023).
Engineering and Science: Civil engineers, electrical & electronics engineers, and scientists (in R&D, laboratory roles) are often needed. Certain engineering roles are on the Shortage List, e.g., civil engineers, design and development engineers for specific fields. Additionally, roles in construction (bricklayers, masons, roofers) were recently added to the Shortage List (in 2023) to support infrastructure projects – reflecting a demand for skilled tradespersons.
Education: There’s demand for secondary school teachers in specific subjects (maths, physics, computer science) and these roles are on the Shortage List. Also, researchers and academics continue to use both Skilled Worker and Global Talent routes to work in UK universities and labs.
Finance and Creative: The UK’s finance sector in London often uses the sponsored route for specialized roles like quantitative analysts or traders, though many high earners come via intra-company transfers (now under the Global Business Mobility routes). In the creative sector, there’s a separate Creative visa for artists, musicians, etc., but some also use the points system if in a salaried role.
Hospitality and Others: Chefs are on the Shortage Occupation List (with specific requirements like role not being a fast-food chef) due to chronic chef shortages in high-end restaurants. This remains a niche but notable category.
Overall, shortage occupation designations (which grant some concessions on salary and fees) currently cover health workers (like nurses, lab technicians), specific engineers, IT/business analysts, architects, veterinarians, and a handful of creative and agriculture roles. The government periodically updates this list. The majority of Skilled Worker visas, though, are granted outside the shortage list, implying many employers simply meet the standard criteria. According to Home Office data, in 2022–2023 the top occupations for sponsored work visas were in programming/IT, healthcare (nurses), management consulting, higher education teaching professionals, and business analysts. This shows the breadth: from hospitals to fintech startups to universities.
Eligibility Criteria & Notable Changes: The UK Skilled Worker route has several key eligibility requirements:
Approved Sponsor and Job Offer: You must have a confirmed job offer from a UK employer who holds a Sponsor Licence. The job must be on the government’s list of eligible occupations (basically RQF3+ skilled jobs) (Skilled Worker visa: Overview - GOV.UK). The employer issues a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) which ties to the job’s details (title, salary, hours) (Skilled Worker visa: Overview - GOV.UK). Without a licensed sponsor, you cannot apply (with limited exceptions for a few unsponsored routes). This is a fundamental difference from Canada/Australia – you cannot apply on your own points merits; the system starts with an employer’s backing.
Skill Level: The job must be at least RQF Level 3 (roughly technician or skilled trade level) or higher (Skilled Worker visa: Overview - GOV.UK). In practice, this includes most professional, managerial, technical, and junior professional roles. It excludes low-skilled work like general labor, waitstaff, etc. For example, a software engineer, lab technician, marketing executive, or plumber qualifies (plumbers meet RQF3). The eligible occupations list is expansive but pointedly omits lower-wage service jobs.
Salary Requirement: The sponsoring employer must pay at least the minimum salary threshold. There are a few different thresholds to meet: generally £26,200/year (or £10.75/hour), or the specific “going rate” for that occupation if higher (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris). Each SOC occupation code has a going rate defined (e.g., for civil engineers it might be ~£33k). The applicant needs to earn the higher of the general threshold or 100% of the going rate to get the required 20 points. There are exceptions: if the job is a shortage occupation or the applicant has a STEM PhD relevant to the job, they can be paid 80–90% of the usual rates and still qualify (trading characteristics). New entrants (younger workers or recent graduates) also have a lower threshold (70% of going rate) for the first few years. Notably, for Health and Education jobs, separate lower salary rules apply, pegged to national pay scales (Skilled Worker Visa Changes: UK Immigration Rules for 2025) – e.g., nurses meet the requirement if paid according to NHS band levels which can be in mid-£20k. For most, though, ~£26k is baseline.
English Language: Applicants must prove English language ability at B1 (intermediate) on the CEFR (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris). This can be shown via an English language test (IELTS for UKVI, etc.) or by having a degree taught in English, or being a national of a majority English-speaking country. This is a mandatory 10 points and essentially a yes/no requirement – most applicants satisfy it either by nationality or a test (Skilled Worker Visa Points Guide | DavidsonMorris).
Other Requirements: Standard background checks apply: you must not fall foul of general grounds for refusal (like certain criminal history, or false documents). Certain roles (e.g., education, healthcare) require a criminal record certificate. There’s no formal education or experience minimum in the immigration rules – theoretically, if an employer is willing to sponsor you and you can do the job, it’s fine, whether you have a degree or not. (Of course, to get the job offer you likely need qualifications, but the immigration system doesn’t separately award points for a PhD or age except via the salary/shortage tradeable mechanism.)
Some notable changes or clarifications up to 2025 include: the Shortage Occupation List is under review, and some roles (like care workers) were added in 2022 to help fill urgent gaps. The government has hinted it might remove some roles if domestic supply improves. So far in 2025, no roles have been removed from shortage list, but care worker status might be revisited given the new domestic recruitment rule. English language criteria remain the same (though the government has made IELTS SELT tests more widely available post-pandemic). There was also a change that migrants must apply from outside the UK if switching from visit visa to skilled work (closing a loophole where people came as visitors then job-hunted and switched; now one must leave the UK to apply in that scenario).
One improvement is that the old cap and monthly quota is gone – there’s no limit to how many skilled visas can be issued, and this won’t change in 2025. Additionally, unlike the past, labor market tests are not broadly required (except for the new care sector measure). This means sponsors don’t have to advertise the position for a set time first in most cases, which expedites hiring. Sponsors do pay a hefty Immigration Skills Charge (up to £5,000 for a 5-year visa), but that burden is on the employer, not counted in points.
Application Process Overview: Getting a UK Skilled Worker visa involves coordination with the employer:
Sponsorship & CoS issuance: First, the UK employer must have a sponsor licence. They will offer you the job and verify that you meet any job-specific requirements (e.g., appropriate degree or experience for the role). The employer then assigns you a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) through the Home Office sponsorship management system. The CoS is an electronic record with a unique reference number; it details your personal info, job title, salary, work start date, and confirmation it meets skill and salary requirements.
Prepare Documents: You’ll need a valid passport, your CoS number, proof of English proficiency (if not exempt), and proof of maintenance funds (if your sponsor hasn’t certified maintenance). Proof of funds means showing you have at least £1,270 available, unless the sponsor ticks a box on the CoS guaranteeing your maintenance (Skilled Worker visa: How much it costs - GOV.UK). Often, sponsors do certify maintenance, simplifying this step.
Visa Application: You apply online on the gov.uk website for a Skilled Worker visa. You’ll pay the application fee (ranges from £769 for a short visa up to £1,519 for a 5-year visa) (Skilled Worker visa: How much it costs - GOV.UK) and the Immigration Health Surcharge (generally £624 per year of visa, though health/care visa applicants are exempt from IHS). During the application, you also book an appointment at a visa application centre (if outside the UK) to submit biometrics (fingerprints and photo). Many countries now offer a “UK Immigration: ID Check” app for biometric passport holders, allowing you to apply and verify identity through your smartphone without visiting a center.
Processing & Decision: UKVI processes most Skilled Worker visa applications from outside the UK within 3 weeks (15 working days) (Skilled Worker visa: Apply from outside the UK - GOV.UK), which is relatively fast. In-country switch or extension applications take about 8 weeks. There are priority services available in many locations for an extra fee to get a decision in 5 working days or even 1 day. Once decided, you’ll get an email. If approved, you’ll either get a visa vignette in your passport (if applied at a center) or an electronic visa linked to your passport (if you used the app). Then you can travel to the UK. If you got a vignette, you must collect a Biometric Residence Permit (BRP) within 10 days of arrival (though BRPs are being phased out by end of 2024 in favor of digital status).
Start Work: You can only start working in the UK once the visa is issued (and valid from up to 14 days before your job start date on the CoS). The visa will be valid for the length of employment up to 5 years (you can get up to 5-year visa at once, which many do to save fees). It is tied to the specific employer and role. If you want to change jobs or employers, you need to apply for a change of employment and get a new CoS.
Extend or Settle: A Skilled Worker visa can be extended indefinitely as long as you still have a qualifying job and sponsor (Skilled Worker visa: Overview - GOV.UK). After 5 years in the UK, you can apply for Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) (permanent settlement) (Skilled Worker visa: Overview - GOV.UK), and after that, citizenship if desired. To get ILR, you also need to meet a minimum salary (currently at least £25,600 or the going rate) and have spent those 5 years continuously in qualifying visas.
Costs and considerations: The total cost for a 5-year Skilled Worker visa for one person is significant: approximately £1,519 fee + £3,120 IHS = £4,639, plus any priority service or legal fees. The UK system thus, while not limiting numbers by quota, does ensure the migrants are skilled (meeting salary and education for the job) and can contribute (through fees and taxes). Dependent spouses and children can join the main applicant, each paying their own fee and IHS. There is no separate points calculation for dependents; they are admitted based on the main applicant’s status.
In 2025, the UK’s points-based system for skilled work is functioning relatively smoothly for employers, with tens of thousands of skilled workers coming in each year. The combination of a firm job offer requirement and government-set salary minimums ensures that migrants have employment and are not filling lower-paid jobs. The trade-off is that it’s less flexible for independent skilled individuals – you can’t move to the UK under this route without a job lined up. For those interested in the UK without a job offer, alternative routes like the High Potential Individual (for recent graduates of top global universities) or the Innovator Founder visa (for entrepreneurs) might be considered, but those are niche. The Skilled Worker remains the main channel for skilled migration to the UK, and understanding its points formula (job + salary + English) is key to navigating it.
Overview: Singapore introduced a points-based evaluation system in September 2023 for its main skilled work visa, the Employment Pass (EP). This system is called COMPASS (Complementarity Assessment Framework) and it applies to new EP applications (and from 2024, renewals) for foreign professionals, managers, and executives. Singapore’s approach is a hybrid – it still requires a job offer with a minimum salary for eligibility, but then uses a points framework to assess the candidate and the hiring firm on various attributes. An EP applicant must score at least 40 points under COMPASS to pass (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September) (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB).
The COMPASS points are split across four foundational criteria and two bonus criteria (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September):
Criterion 1: Salary – compares the applicant’s proposed salary against local salaries in that sector. If the salary is above the 90th percentile, 20 points (“exceeds expectations”); around median (~50th percentile) gets 10 points; below a certain threshold gets 0 (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September).
Criterion 2: Qualifications – looks at the applicant’s educational credentials. Top-tier degrees (or equivalent professional qualifications) score 20; a basic degree or equivalent is 10; if no degree or one not recognized, 0.
Criterion 3: Diversity – examines how the candidate’s nationality is represented in the firm’s professional workforce. If the firm doesn’t have many people of the same nationality (i.e., the candidate adds to diversity), 20 points; moderate diversity 10; if the firm is already dominated by that nationality, 0.
Criterion 4: Support for Local Employment – looks at the company’s employment of local (Singaporean) professionals. If the company has a high share of local PMETs (professionals, managers, executives, technicians) relative to industry peers, it scores 20; average share 10; low share 0.
Each of these four has a maximum of 20 points, and “meeting expectations” generally yields 10 points (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September). In many cases an application will score 10 on most and need at least one criterion to score higher to reach 40.
Additionally, there are bonus points that do not have negative scoring (you either get them or not):
Criterion 5: Skills Bonus (Shortage Occupation List) – If the job is on Singapore’s official Shortage Occupation List (SOL), the candidate gets +20 bonus points (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September) (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB) (or +10 if the hiring firm already has a lot of that same nationality, to prevent clustering (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September)). The SOL, introduced with COMPASS, includes specialized roles in agritech, financial services, green economy, healthcare, infocomm tech, and maritime – 27 occupations ranging from AI engineers and software developers to nurses and carbon traders.
Criterion 6: Strategic Economic Priorities Bonus – If the employer is actively partnering on national strategic initiatives (such as certain innovation or internationalization programmes with government agencies), the application gets +10 or +20 points (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). This encourages companies contributing to Singapore’s economic agenda (e.g., R&D investments, industry transformation projects).
An EP application passes if the total points ≥ 40 (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). High salary or qualifications can compensate for weaker firm-based scores and vice versa. For example, a small company that doesn’t yet have many locals (thus low on C4) might still get an EP approved if they pay the candidate a very high salary (scoring 20 on C1) and the candidate has a good degree (10 on C2) and they contribute to diversity (10 on C3), totaling 40. On the other hand, a company with strong local employment and diversity might get their candidate through even if the salary is just average.
It’s important to note baseline conditions: to even apply for an EP (and thus come under COMPASS), the job must meet the minimum qualifying monthly salary, which is SGD $5,000 (and higher at $5,500 for finance sector roles) for new applications (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September). This salary minimum increases with the candidate’s age (older applicants need higher pay to qualify). Also, the job must be a managerial, executive or specialized role. Lower roles fall under S Pass or Work Permit, which are separate frameworks. So COMPASS essentially fine-tunes which white-collar professionals get the EP, ensuring they complement the local workforce.
2025 Updates & Trends: Since COMPASS is newly implemented (only a few months old by 2025), much of the focus is on transition and initial impact:
Full Implementation: As of September 2023, COMPASS applies to all new EP applications, and from September 2024 it also applies to renewal EP applications (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September). By 2025, a large portion of EP holders coming up for renewal will start being evaluated on COMPASS criteria as well. Companies that historically hired many foreign PMETs now need to maintain local hiring or workforce diversity to ensure smooth renewals. We expect some firms to adjust salaries or hiring practices to score better (e.g., hiring more locals in parallel, or increasing offered salaries to ensure 40 points).
Shortage Occupation List (SOL) Management: The government will periodically update the SOL (the initial list was called “inaugural”). Trends in 2025 may include adding or removing occupations based on Singapore’s economic needs. For instance, if Singapore pushes further into green tech or biotech, we might see new niche roles added to SOL. The existence of SOL bonus means foreign specialists in those areas have easier EP approval. The infocomm technology roles (like AI, cybersecurity, software dev) dominate the list, reflecting Singapore’s continued demand for tech talent. The government is likely to keep these in shortage until local supply catches up. Healthcare roles (like nurses and therapists) are also on the list as Singapore grapples with an aging population and needs more healthcare workers. In 2025, this trend continues – healthcare and tech are still hard-to-fill locally, so expect them to remain priority.
Rising Qualifying Salaries: Singapore has been steadily raising the EP minimum salary to ensure EP holders are truly high-skilled. It went from $4,500 to $5,000 (general) in 2022–2023 (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September). It would not be surprising if by late 2025 or 2026, the threshold is raised again (perhaps $5,500 general, $6,000 finance) to keep pace with wage growth. Higher salary thresholds naturally make COMPASS easier to pass on Criterion 1, but restrict the volume of EPs to more senior positions.
Employer Adjustments: Early anecdotal evidence suggests some firms have reacted by boosting local hiring or re-balancing nationality mix to do better on C3 and C4. Singapore’s aim is to improve local-foreigner complementarity, not necessarily to reduce foreign hires, but to encourage quality. Companies in 2025 might increase salaries for particularly critical foreign hires to maximize points (e.g., paying above market to hit the 90th percentile for 20 points). They also might be more selective – focusing on candidates who have good qualifications (since a candidate without at least a bachelor’s might score 0 on C2, jeopardizing the 40-point total).
Exemptions: Some categories are exempt from COMPASS, including very high earners (fixed monthly salary ≥ SGD $22,500) (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB), short-term assignments (1 month or less), and intra-corporate transferees under trade agreements (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). In 2025, these exemptions remain, meaning ultra-high-paid roles basically skip the points test (the logic being if a company is willing to pay such a premium, the candidate is clearly valued). Most regular EPs, however, will go through COMPASS.
In summary, 2025 is the first full year of COMPASS in action. The early trend is greater transparency – firms can use a Self-Assessment Tool to estimate a candidate’s points in advance (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB) (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). If a candidate falls short (say only hits 34 points), the firm might reconsider the hire or adjust terms. Singapore’s government will monitor outcomes to ensure COMPASS is meeting its objectives of encouraging diversity and local workforce development without unduly harming business growth. So far, no major changes to the framework have been needed, and it’s generally well-received as a balanced approach.
Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: Singapore’s economy highly values tech, finance, and healthcare talent, among others. The introduction of the Shortage Occupation List provides a clear view of roles Singapore considers in critical short supply domestically:
In Tech (Infocomm Technology): Roles like Artificial Intelligence Scientist/Engineer, Software Developer, Applications Programmer, Cybersecurity Specialist, Data Scientist, Digital Forensics Specialist, and Product Manager (Digital) are on the SOL. This reflects Singapore’s drive to be a digital hub. The country is home to many multinational tech firms’ Asian HQs, as well as a growing startup scene, creating strong demand for software and data professionals. Local graduates in these fields are increasing but not yet enough, hence these foreign specialists are needed.
In Finance: While Singapore has a strong local finance workforce, niche areas like wealth management for ultra-high-net-worth clients and family offices have roles such as Financial/Investment Adviser (UHNW) on the SOL. Singapore’s status as a wealth management hub means it needs talent with specialized knowledge and networks. Additionally, roles in risk management and sustainable finance (like carbon trading) appear on the list under Green Economy.
In the Green Economy: New roles like Carbon Trader, Carbon Standards and Methodology Analyst, Carbon Project Manager are listed. This is in line with Singapore’s initiative to develop carbon trading and sustainability expertise as it commits to climate goals. These skills are quite niche globally, so Singapore is signalling openness to foreign experts to build this sector.
In Healthcare: Singapore’s shortage of healthcare professionals is evidenced by roles such as Clinical Psychologist, Diagnostic Radiographer, Occupational Therapist, Physiotherapist, and Registered Nurse on the SOL. This is significant because Singapore traditionally limited foreign nurses, trying to train locals; adding nurses to SOL shows the demand is acute. The healthcare sector will likely continue to rely on a mix of local and foreign professionals to staff hospitals and care facilities.
In Agritech: Niche roles like Alternative Protein Food Scientist and Novel Food Biotechnologist are on the list, aligning with Singapore’s food tech push (like lab-grown meat and sustainable foods) due to its food security strategy.
In Maritime: Roles such as Marine Superintendent and Technical Superintendent made the SOL. The maritime sector is a backbone of Singapore’s economy (shipping, ports). These roles require deep experience; bringing in foreign marine engineers or ex-sea captains helps maintain Singapore’s maritime standards.
Beyond the SOL, generally IT and financial services have been the top EP-attracting sectors historically. Also, manufacturing R&D and electronics (semiconductor engineers, etc.) are in demand, though many of those roles might be on S Pass if mid-level. Biotechnology and pharmaceuticals sectors in Singapore’s biomedical hub also seek talent (e.g., biochemists, regulatory affairs specialists).
Another high-demand area is hospitality and F&B management – while lower-level service jobs are for locals or Work Permit holders, many hotels and restaurants hire foreign managers or chefs (indeed specialized chefs for cuisine can get EPs if paid enough). However, those aren’t shortage-listed because they’re not strategic shortages, but they do constitute a chunk of EP jobs.
In short, tech remains king in demand, healthcare is rising in priority, and frontier fields like carbon services and agritech are newly highlighted. Singapore’s tight labor market (2.1% unemployment) means across many industries there is a need for skilled workers. The COMPASS system doesn’t bar any particular occupations (as long as salary and skill level are met), but it nudges employers to pay well and maintain a balance.
Eligibility Criteria & Notable Changes: To qualify for an EP under COMPASS, an applicant must:
Have a Job Offer from a Singapore Employer: You cannot apply for an EP independently; a company in Singapore must apply on your behalf. The company must be a legitimate business entity and will be evaluated (for criteria C3 and C4).
Meet the Minimum Salary: For a new EP in 2025, the fixed monthly salary must be at least SGD $5,000 (and higher for older candidates – e.g., a 40-year-old might need ~$10k) (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September). If in the financial sector, $5,500 is the base for young applicants. This salary criterion is strict – if you don’t meet it, you have to go for an S Pass (mid-skilled visa) instead.
Score 40 Points on COMPASS: As explained, this involves meeting various benchmarks. In practical terms, a candidate with at least a bachelor’s degree and a decent salary relative to the industry will usually score at least half the points. The notable “at-risk” cases would be: someone without a recognized degree (0 points on C2), or someone coming into a company that already employs many foreigners of the same nationality (0 on C3) and that company has a low local ratio (0 on C4). Those cases might fail. Thus, eligibility via points can sometimes depend on the employer’s profile as much as the candidate’s. This is unique to Singapore – it’s assessing the complementarity aspect (hence COMPASS). A notable feature is small companies (fewer than 25 PMET employees) automatically get 10 points on both C3 and C4 by default (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September), so startups aren’t penalized.
Education/Qualifications: While not an absolute requirement to have a degree, it heavily influences the COMPASS score. A Bachelor’s or higher is strongly advisable. Some exceptional talents without degrees might qualify if compensated by high salary (e.g., a proven tech entrepreneur could be hired at >90th percentile pay, scoring well on salary, and maybe the firm gets diversity points). But generally, lack of a degree makes EP difficult now. This is a shift; in the past, some experienced candidates without degrees got EPs if salary was met – now they risk 0 on one criterion.
Other Requirements: Standard Singapore work visa requirements still apply: the candidate must be of good character (criminal background checks for certain sensitive industries), and medically fit (health screening for some diseases may be required for passes). There is also an age consideration: while there’s no formal age limit for EP, the salary requirement scales with age. If someone is well into their 50s or 60s, a very high salary would be needed to justify EP (because they expect a senior position).
Notable changes recently were the introduction of COMPASS itself – a big change from the old system where if you met salary and basic criteria, EP approval was largely discretionary but straightforward. Now it’s rules-based and somewhat tougher for certain firms. Additionally, Singapore had raised the qualifying salary in stages (it was $3,600 a few years ago, now $5,000) (Singapore’s New COMPASS System Set to Roll Out in September), reflecting the push to encourage hiring of truly high-skilled roles on EP and use S Pass for mid-level. The Dependency Ratio Ceiling (a limit on proportion of foreign workers) does not apply to EPs (it applies to lower passes), but effectively COMPASS’s firm-related criteria encourage a healthy ratio of locals to foreigners.
One more change is the creation of a 5-year EP option for tech professionals on the SOL, provided they earn at least $10,500/month. This was an initiative (Tech.Pass) to attract and retain critical tech talent longer. So a software engineer hired at $11k/month can get a 5-year EP instead of the usual 2-3 year duration, giving stability. This is an added incentive in those shortage roles.
Application Process Overview: The process for obtaining an EP under COMPASS is:
Employer Applies via EP Online: The hiring company submits the EP application through Singapore’s Ministry of Manpower (MOM) online portal. They will input the candidate’s details, salary, job info, and attach supporting documents (like the candidate’s education certificates, CV, passport, and testimonials).
Document Verification: New rules require employers to verify educational qualifications for EP candidates who are claiming points for them (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). This might involve uploading verified true copies or verification proof (e.g., through a global verification agency). This step was introduced to combat fake degrees.
MOM Assessment: The Ministry of Manpower will evaluate the application. First, they check basic salary threshold and authenticity of documents. Then they run the COMPASS scoring. Many of these checks are automated or formula-based now. If the 40-point mark is met (and no disqualifiers), the EP is usually approved swiftly. If it’s marginal or there are concerns, an officer might review more closely or ask for additional info from the employer.
Outcome: Processing time for EPs is typically within 3-4 weeks, although Singapore reports 85% of applications get an outcome in ~3 weeks. If approved, an In-Principle Approval (IPA) letter is issued to the employer and candidate. The candidate can then travel to Singapore (if not already there) and go through a short issuance process (including possibly a medical check-up depending on nationality). The IPA serves as a single-entry visa to enter Singapore to finalize the formalities.
EP Issuance: Upon arrival, the candidate goes to the MOM’s designated center to get fingerprints and photo taken for the EP card, and the employer pays the issuance fee (and a security bond for some nationalities). Then the EP card (biometric ID) is issued – this is the work permit ID card.
Post-Arrival: An EP holder can start work immediately upon obtaining the IPA or upon arrival, as the IPA is proof of permission. They must undertake registration with tax authority for taxes after starting. EP is typically granted for 2 years for first timers (some get 3). As noted, certain SOL tech professionals can get 5 years. Spouses and children can accompany on Dependants’ Pass (for legally married spouses and kids under 21) or Long-Term Visit Pass (for unmarried partners or elderly parents, subject to salary >= $6k or $12k respectively).
The fees for an EP application are relatively low (about S$105 to apply and S$225 on issuance, total S$330). Singapore deliberately keeps work visa fees modest to not deter businesses. Instead, they manage volume through criteria rather than cost.
If an application fails to meet 40 points, MOM will reject it. Employers can appeal, especially if they have additional info (e.g., “we actually are part of a strategic economic program” which might not have been counted initially). Appeals may succeed if a compelling case or new evidence is provided, but generally one must improve some aspect (like offer a higher salary or adjust role) to overturn a points shortfall.
Overall, Singapore’s process is efficient and entirely employer-driven. By 2025, companies are getting accustomed to COMPASS. The government even provided a Self-Assessment Tool where employers can plug in details to see if an applicant would score 40 (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB) (Singapore’s Employment Pass – All you need to know about the Complementarity Assessment Framework | Singapore EDB). This transparency helps avoid futile applications. If a candidate doesn’t pass the self-check, the employer might consider them for an S Pass (for mid-level skilled workers, which has its own quota and levy and a different points system called COMPASS for S Pass, launching later).
One more note: if an EP applicant does not qualify under COMPASS, they cannot get an EP. They might try for an S Pass (which has lower salary requirement ~$3k but different conditions and also a points system of its own being introduced). However, S Pass is generally for technicians and junior staff, whereas EP is for professionals. There is also a new ONE Pass (Overseas Networks & Expertise Pass) for very high earners (S$30,000 monthly) or top achievers – which is a 5-year personal employment pass with no points test. Only a select few qualify, but it exists as a draw for elite global talent. For the typical skilled foreign professional though, EP via COMPASS is the route.
Singapore’s system in 2025 aims to ensure quality over quantity: by using points to filter, Singapore maintains openness to global talent in the areas it truly needs (tech, finance, innovation), while safeguarding opportunities for locals and encouraging firms to develop local talent alongside. It’s a balancing act, and COMPASS is the tool designed for that balance.
Overview: New Zealand re-opened its Skilled Migrant Category (SMC) in October 2023 after a hiatus, with a new points-based residency system that is simpler than the old one. The SMC is New Zealand’s primary pathway for skilled workers to obtain permanent residence (PR). Under the new system, applicants need to score 6 points to be eligible for residency (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). This small number belies a significant change: previously, the system had a 100+ point scale with many factors; now it’s been streamlined to essentially a 6-point threshold focusing on key indicators of skill.
Points can come from one of three “skill categories” (choose the single category that benefits you most) (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand) (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration):
Qualification: Points for your highest educational qualification. A Bachelor’s degree (Level 7 NZQF) gives 3 points, a Master’s or postgraduate (Level 9) gives 4 points, and a Doctoral degree (Level 10) gives 6 points (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration). You can only claim one – whichever is highest. (If your qualification is overseas, it must be recognized as equivalent via the NZQA assessment unless it’s from certain exempt countries).
New Zealand Occupational Registration: If your occupation is one that requires formal registration in New Zealand (e.g., doctors, lawyers, electricians, many trades), you can get points based on the years of training/experience needed for that registration. Typically, getting the full registration that requires ≥6 years of training yields 6 points, lesser requirements yield 3–5 points (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements - Aspiring Immigration) (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration).
Income: Points based on your salary relative to the NZ median wage. If your job or job offer pays at least 1.5 times the median wage, you get 3 points; if it’s 3 times the median wage, you get 6 points (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration). (As of late 2023, the median wage was NZD $29.66/hour, so 1.5x ~ $44.49/hour, which annualized is about $92,000/year; 3x is ~$184,000/year – that high threshold targets top executives or specialists.)
Crucially, you cannot combine these primary points from multiple categories – you pick the one category where you score highest (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). Many people will end up with 3 points from one of those (e.g., a bachelor’s degree). To reach the required 6, you can then add points for work experience in New Zealand: you get 1 point per year of skilled work in NZ, up to 3 points max (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand) (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration). This is the only instance where you can combine; these NZ work points can top up the category points. For example, someone with a Bachelor’s (3 points) who has worked 3 years in NZ (3 points) reaches 6. Or someone with 3x median wage salary (6 points) qualifies instantly without needing NZ experience.
Besides points, there are some core requirements: every applicant must have a skilled job or job offer in New Zealand to even apply under SMC (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). “Skilled” is defined as either the job is on ANZSCO Level 1-3 and paid at or above the median wage, or if it’s on Levels 4-5 (lower-skilled categories) it must be paid at least 1.5x median (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). So essentially, you need a job offer at or above median wage in a recognized occupation, and the employer needs to be accredited (all employers hiring migrants in NZ need accreditation under new rules) (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). Unlike Canada/Australia, New Zealand’s system effectively requires a job offer for skilled migration – it’s not a pure points pool where you can apply without a job. (They closed that avenue; now if you don’t have a job, you can’t apply for SMC, though if you have very high points like PhD 6, they might consider but generally a job is expected).
Also, age limit: you must be 55 or younger to apply (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). And you need to meet English language requirements (usually an IELTS score of 6.5 or proof of English-speaking background) (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand), as well as standard health and character (police clearance) requirements.
This new 6-point system is much more straightforward and transparent compared to the old system. It basically focuses on: are you qualified? do you earn well? do you have NZ work experience? If yes, you’re likely in. If not, you might not qualify for residency directly, although there are other pathways like the Green List or Work to Residence programs for specific occupations.
2025 Updates & Trends: The re-opened SMC in late 2023 came with a cap on the number of resident visas issued via SMC per year. For the first 18 months, New Zealand set a maximum of only 3,000 SMC residence approvals (per year) while they manage demand. They instituted selection rounds (draws) from the EOI pool every 2 months, with a certain number of EOIs selected each time. In 2024, initial selection drew around 600 EOIs (covering perhaps 1,500 people including family). By 2025, demand is expected to be strong as many migrants working in NZ (on Work to Residence visas, etc.) seek to become residents. We anticipate the cap might increase if needed, but currently it means not everyone who qualifies will immediately get residency – they go into a queue.
However, in late 2024 the government indicated it plans to remove the cap and EOI pool by end of 2023 or early 2024, moving to a fully demand-driven system again (taking all applicants who qualify, similar to Canada). If that happens, by 2025 anyone who hits 6 points and other criteria can directly apply without a lottery. So this is something to watch: the system may transition from selection rounds to first-come, first-served processing once backlog stabilizes.
Another trend: New Zealand introduced special pathways outside SMC, such as the Green List Straight to Residence route (for very highly skilled roles like surgeons, engineers, tech architects) and Green List Work to Residence (for nurses, teachers, etc., where you work 2 years then get residence). In 2023–2024, many people eligible for those used them. But the government signaled the Green List might be phased out in favor of just using SMC points, since SMC now covers most scenarios. By 2025, we might see an integration or simplification: possibly more occupations (like nurses, teachers) being encouraged into SMC by recognizing their qualifications/registration for full points. For instance, a Nurse registered in NZ gets 6 points via occupational registration, hence qualifies immediately for SMC, essentially mirroring the Straight-to-Residence outcome.
Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: New Zealand’s labor shortages mirror some global trends but also have local specifics. Key sectors include:
Healthcare and Aged Care: New Zealand badly needs doctors, nurses, and allied health professionals. Nurses and specialists appear on the Green List for fast-track residency. In SMC terms, these professions require NZ registration (which gives 6 points if it’s a lengthy qualification). The healthcare workforce shortage is driving a lot of skilled migration demand, especially after COVID.
Construction and Infrastructure: Roles like civil engineers, structural engineers, project managers, quantity surveyors, electricians, plumbers are in demand due to housing and infrastructure projects. Many construction trades are on skills shortage lists. For example, electricians require occupational registration in NZ – achieving that gives 6 points, hence an immediate residency pathway.
IT and Technology: Software developers, ICT managers, cybersecurity experts, multimedia specialists are sought after. Tech jobs in NZ might not pay as high as in Silicon Valley, but many will cross 1.5x median wage (the median is low ~NZ$60k/year, so a $90k tech salary yields 3 points). NZ competes with Australia for tech talent, so offering residency is a key attraction.
Engineering and Science: Beyond construction, mechanical engineers, electrical engineers, environmental scientists, food technologists etc., are needed for NZ’s industries (dairy, manufacturing, renewable energy projects). Many of these are on the Green List, meaning NZ wants them permanently.
Education: Teachers (especially secondary STEM teachers) and early childhood educators have shortages. They have a special work-to-residence path. Under SMC, a teacher with NZ registration (which takes some doing) could get 6 points via occupational registration.
Primary Industries: NZ, being an agricultural economy, needs veterinarians, agricultural consultants, farm managers and in some cases horticulture and wine industry specialists. Vets, for instance, are on the Green List (Straight to Residence). Also, chef is a role often in shortage for hospitality – experienced chefs can potentially qualify via salary points if they earn above 1.5x median (some do in resort areas).
One interesting addition: PhD holders now have a clear pathway. If you have a PhD (6 points), you qualify for SMC without a NZ job or experience (technically you meet 6). However, since a job offer is required by policy, a PhD alone isn’t sufficient – but the assumption is a PhD-level person will likely get a skilled job easily. In fact, there’s talk of allowing direct residence to high-caliber candidates even without a job if they have e.g. a PhD from a top institution. But currently, the job offer requirement stands for SMC.
Eligibility Criteria & Notable Changes: Summarizing the criteria for the new SMC:
Age: 55 or under (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand).
Skilled Job/Job Offer: Required. The job must meet skill level and wage tests (≥ median wage for most, or 1.5x for lower-skill roles) (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). And the employer must be Accredited (most medium/large employers are, small employers have to apply for accreditation to hire any migrant).
Points: 6 points total from (Qualification or Registration or Income) + NZ work experience (if needed to reach
English: Principal applicant and their partner (if included) must show at least IELTS 6.5 (which is the standard for NZ residence) unless exempt by nationality or prior education. Dependents 16+ need slightly lower (IELTS 5.0). This requirement was unchanged in the new system – English remains vital.
Health & Character: Medical exam and police certificates from all countries of long residence are needed. NZ strictly filters out applicants with serious health issues that could cost the health system (unless they get waivers), and those with criminal convictions may be refused.
Notable changes in this new system compared to pre-2020: It eliminated many minor points factors (like points for age – ironically age no longer gives points, it’s just an upper limit; points for having family in NZ; points for being in a region; etc., all gone). It also removed the old pool selection point which had risen to 160; now it’s just 6 (in concept, equivalent but simplified). Requiring a job offer is actually a continuation – historically NZ almost always wanted a job for SMC, though pre-2017 one could apply without a job if points were high enough; that avenue is essentially closed now unless maybe you have a PhD and claim you’ll find a job quickly.
A transitional detail: Between Sept and Oct 2023, NZ selected some EOIs under an interim system at 180 points and some under new system. By 2025 everything is under the new system.
It’s also worth noting partners of SMC applicants can now be non-secondary (meaning even if the partner doesn’t speak English or is over 55, they cannot be included) (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration). Actually, partners over 55 can’t be included by the rule. If a partner doesn’t meet English, you can pre-purchase English classes for them to satisfy criteria.
Application Process Overview: The process for the Skilled Migrant Category in NZ typically works as follows:
Submit an Expression of Interest (EOI): Applicants first lodge an EOI (online) detailing their qualifications, job, income, work experience, etc. They must include a valid job offer (with details of employer, position, pay) or current employment. There’s a fee for EOI (around NZD $700). If you claim exactly 6 points, you can submit; if you have more (say you have 7 or 8 due to extra NZ years or a combination like qual+income, you still just mark those but points beyond 6 don’t give priority as long as you meet 6).
Selection from Pool: EOIs used to be pooled and drawn bi-monthly (with highest points first if limited). As mentioned, the intention is to remove this selection stage so that all EOIs meeting criteria proceed immediately. But if the selection is ongoing in 2025 due to caps, the highest point EOIs or earliest EOIs might be selected first. So far, an EOI with the minimum 6 points and a job was enough to get selected in the first rounds because the pool was not oversubscribed.
Invitation to Apply (ITA): If selected, Immigration NZ issues an Invitation to Apply. The applicant then has 4 months to submit a full Residence Application (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration).
Application Submission: The residence application requires extensive documentation: job offer letter and employer evidence, proof of qualifications (with NZQA assessment if foreign and not exempt), proof of work experience (letters from previous employers if claiming NZ years), salary evidence (pay slips, contract), English test results, medical exam reports, police certificates, etc. The application can be submitted online (with uploads) or paper depending on system readiness, and the fee is significant – NZD $4,890 (plus $1,110 if including a partner, and $620 per child). In total, including EOI stage, the cost starts at NZD $6,450 for a single applicant (Skilled Migrant Category Requirements — Aspiring Immigration). This steep fee was newly set in 2023, making NZ’s skilled visa one of the more expensive, likely to fund the detailed processing involved.
Assessment by INZ: An immigration officer will assess the application. They verify the points and may conduct checks like contacting the employer or checking the genuineness of the job, as well as ensuring the employer attempted to hire locals (though accredited employers generally have passed labor market tests for some roles already). They also verify credentials (NZQA evaluations, professional registrations). This can take a few months. Under the new system, INZ also limits how many applications they process monthly to manage the cap, so some applications wait in queue even after submission.
Decision: If all is in order, the applicant (and included family) are granted Resident Visas. Initially, it’s often conditional with “travel conditions” for 2 years. After 2 years of actually residing in NZ, one can get a Permanent Resident visa with indefinite travel rights. If the officer has concerns (e.g., suspecting the job isn’t truly skilled or permanent), they might decline or defer. There is no formal interview usually, but they might ask for additional info.
Settlement: Once resident, you have almost all rights of a citizen except voting (until you’ve been resident long enough) and some public service jobs. Notably, unlike Canada/Australia, NZ grants residency outright (no temporary stage in SMC), so it’s a direct path to living permanently in NZ from the get-go.
Given it’s a new system, processing times in early 2024 were a bit untested, but INZ aimed to process most within 6 months of application. By 2025, we hope processing will be 4-6 months on average (assuming volume is manageable).
For those who don’t quite fit SMC, New Zealand offers other residence paths: - Green List Straight to Residence: e.g., anesthetists, oncologists, certain engineers – these can apply for PR after securing a job in those roles (no point system, just criteria). - Work to Residence: e.g., registered nurses, teachers, trades like electricians, where after 2 years work you can get residence. - Highly Paid Path: if you earn 2x median wage and work 2 years, you can get residence (this roughly aligns with someone who would have gotten 6 points from income + NZ exp anyway).
In effect, the SMC 6-point model has been designed to encapsulate those scenarios: e.g., a nurse has NZ registration (6 points) = Straight to residence; an electrician has registration (6) = straight to res; a teacher has registration (maybe counted as 6); a software developer might have just a Bachelor’s but after 3 years in NZ gets to 6; a very high earner (>3x median) gets 6 outright.
All in all, New Zealand’s skilled immigration in 2025 is catering to those who have secured skilled employment in NZ and proven their value either by credentials or by local experience. It is friendly to graduates who study in NZ then work (since they accumulate NZ experience points), and to those in regulated professions. It’s less accessible than Canada’s system for those outside NZ without a job, but once you’re working in NZ, the residency pathway is quite straightforward if you meet the skill definitions. The reduction to a 6-point scale has made it much easier for applicants to self-assess – you either meet a key threshold or you don’t, no complex calculus of dozens of points.
One must keep an eye on policy tweaks: if too many people qualify, NZ might tighten (like raise the income thresholds or cap the program). Conversely, if critical shortages persist, they might expand eligibility (like giving points for slightly lower incomes in urgent fields). As of 2025, the settings seem to be working as intended – bringing in needed talent and converting those already contributing in NZ to residents.
Overview: Germany, known for its strong industrial base and aging population, enacted a Skilled Workers Immigration Act overhaul in 2023 to attract more foreign talent. A key component is the introduction of a points-based system for job seekers called the “Chancenkarte” or Opportunity Card. Effective from June 1, 2024, eligible non-EU skilled workers can obtain this Opportunity Card to come to Germany without a job offer for up to 12 months to seek employment (Moving to Germany as a skilled worker - Federal Foreign Office). It’s essentially a job-search visa (not direct permanent residency) and is the first time Germany has used a points-based selection in its labor migration.
To qualify, an applicant must score at least 6 points under Germany’s criteria (Moving to Germany as a skilled worker - Federal Foreign Office). The points factors include (Moving to Germany as a skilled worker - Federal Foreign Office) (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy):
Education Qualification: Having a university degree or a recognized professional qualification is a baseline requirement. In the points system, this isn’t explicitly a point score but is an eligibility must for most. (If your qualification is recognized in Germany or equivalent to German degrees, that’s one box checked. If not recognized, you might not qualify at all for the Chancenkarte.)
Language Skills: German language ability and/or English language ability count. Specifically, German skills at at least B2 level (upper intermediate) can give 3 points, which is the maximum for language. If one doesn’t have German, having English at B2 can count instead (they’ve indicated English can substitute for German at least initially for scoring) (Moving to Germany as a skilled worker - Federal Foreign Office). So language is a significant factor – speaking German opens more doors, but speaking English is also considered given global nature of many industries.
Work Experience: Professional work experience of at least 2 years in the field of your training or degree gives 2 points. The idea is to favor those who not only have a degree but have practical experience.
Age: Being young gives an advantage. If you are under 35 years old, you get 2 points (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). Older candidates (35 and up) presumably get 0 for this factor, though there might be a partial point for slightly older (not clear, but likely it’s binary: <35=2, ≥35=0). - Connection to Germany: Having a previous stay in Germany (for at least 6 months, e.g., former exchange student, working holiday, etc.) gives 1 point (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). This indicates familiarity with the country, language, or culture, which may ease integration. - Spouse Accompanying: If the applicant has a spouse/partner who also qualifies under the points system, that gives 1 point as well (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). Essentially, bringing a skilled partner (who also could contribute to the labor market) is seen positively. The points add up, and as long as you reach 6, you pass. For example, a 30-year-old software developer with a university degree, 3 years experience, and B2 English (but no German) might score: Degree (required, but not points), English B2 (counts like language points – possibly 1 or 2, though the example given is German B2=3; unclear if English B2 gets full 3 or slightly less, but suppose 2), experience 2, age 2, previous stay 0, spouse 0=maybe 6. On the other hand, someone who is 40 with great experience but no German might fall short: age 0, German 0 (English B2 maybe 2?), experience 2, degree yes, connection 0, spouse 0=likely 4, not enough. There are also base conditions: the person must be able to support themselves financially while in Germany (show proof of funds) (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy); must not have a negative record; and must meet criteria of having either a recognized degree or vocational training. If the person already has a job offer and meets simpler criteria, they wouldn’t use the points route – they’d use the standard work permit which doesn’t need points. This Opportunity Card is specifically to come find a job. It’s also limited to 12 months (renewable once) (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). During that time, you can work up to 20 hours/week in any job (to support yourself or as trial employment) (Moving to Germany as a skilled worker - Federal Foreign Office), but you’re supposed to be primarily searching for qualified employment. If you find a skilled job, you can convert to a standard work residence permit or EU Blue Card. 2025 Updates & Trends: Since the Opportunity Card was brand new in 2024, 2025 is the first full year of its implementation. We anticipate: - Interest and Uptake: Germany expected this to attract qualified individuals from around the world. By 2025, the number of applicants and approvals will indicate success. Early commentary suggests interest from professionals in countries like India, Brazil, etc., who see Germany as an opportunity. However, the bureaucracy and requirements (like recognizing qualifications, needing German/English proficiency) mean it’s not a free-for-all. The government also increased funding for Goethe-Institut German language courses abroad, expecting that language could be a barrier (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). We’ll see many prospective applicants taking German classes to improve their chances. - Adjustment of Criteria: If too few people apply or qualify, Germany might tweak the points. For example, they might lower the language level required or give points for A2 German (basic level). Or they could allow older candidates by giving partial age points. Conversely, if too many apply, they might leave it as is or tighten if needed. For now, 6 points is not hard to achieve for a young, educated professional, so Germany likely will get a decent pool. The key choke point might be degree recognition – they require foreign degrees to be comparable; the anabin database or specific evaluation is needed. If many degrees aren’t recognized, that could slow issuance. - Integration with Other Reforms: Germany also eased rules for its regular work visas in 2023: for instance, they scrapped the requirement of matching your degree to the job in some cases, and lowered the salary for EU Blue Card. The Opportunity Card complements these by allowing entry without a job. 2025 may see marketing of this route to target professions Germany lacks, like IT, engineers, craftspeople. Germany is facing severe shortages in skilled trades and healthcare. However, note: to use the Chancenkarte, one typically needs a degree or vocational training; what about tradespeople without formal degrees? They included “vocational qualification” as eligible, so a non-academic tradesperson could qualify if their training is recognized. This is important because Germany needs electricians, plumbers, etc. So we might see craft workers from say, South Asia or Latin America using the points route if they have formal training and some German skills. - Limitations: The points system’s scope is limited compared to Canadian/Aussie systems (Germany: A Points System for Labour Migration and a Hidden Gem – EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy). It’s exclusively for job search – not a direct PR and not for those who already have a job offer (they have other routes). So it’s a narrow funnel. It’s more akin to a “talent visa” to bring people in prospectively. By 2025, the government will evaluate how many Opportunity Cards convert to actual employment and then to longer-term residence. If many holders struggle to find a job within a year, they might adjust support programs (like job matching services). But if successful, it could be expanded. Key Occupations & Sectors in Demand: Germany’s needs span many sectors, which is why they’re opening more pathways. Some critical shortage areas are: - IT and Software: German companies and startups need more software developers, AI specialists, and IT project managers. Tech roles often require English more than German, so the Chancenkarte is attractive for IT professionals (especially if they have good English – they could qualify and then learn German on the ground). The government is keen on digitalizing the economy and attracting tech workers, as competition with other EU countries is high. - Engineering: Mechanical, electrical, civil engineers – Germany’s core industries (automotive, manufacturing, green energy) require lots of engineers. Many German engineering grads are not enough to replace retirees. Having foreign engineers come via job search could help regions facing shortages (like Eastern Germany or smaller firms). - Skilled Trades: Electricians, plumbers, heating installers, metalworkers – these trades are in severe shortage due to an aging workforce. Germany has even considered recruiting abroad for crafts. These roles typically require German vocational qualifications or equivalent. The Opportunity Card might be used by, say, a trained electrician from abroad (with some German knowledge) to come get licensed and work. Recognizing vocational qualifications is tricky, but Germany is trying to speed up that process (with new recognition centers, etc. as part of reforms). - Healthcare: Nurses and elder care workers are in very short supply. Germany has separate programs with specific countries (like agreements with Philippines) to bring nurses, which involve language training. The Opportunity Card might not be first choice for nurses because you’d need B2 German and to pass nursing recognition exams – a tall order to do on your own. However, doctors (with degrees) might use it. Foreign physicians often need to improve German and take medical knowledge exams; with the card they could come, prepare and pass exams to get licensed. - Science & Research: Researchers or scientists might use the Opportunity Card to find roles in academia or R&D. However, Germany also has the EU Blue Card and research visas which are easier if you have a job offer. So likely scientists will go via direct offers, not job search. - Young Graduates: A key target might be young foreign graduates (maybe those who finished university in their home country but have no job yet). Germany’s points allow fresh grads if they have language and age on their side. Many such individuals might consider Germany to start their career, especially in fields like IT or engineering. It’s worth mentioning Germany already has a jobseeker visa (6 months) for those with degrees, but that one required a degree and proof of funds but no points. The new Chancenkarte extends that to 1 year and includes those with vocational training, and uses points to broaden eligibility (someone with slightly lower qualification could compensate with language etc.). Eligibility Criteria & Notable Changes: Summarizing the Opportunity Card eligibility: - Education: You need either a university degree or a vocational training qualification that is recognized in Germany. This isComparative Analysis: Points Systems Similarities & Differences Points-based skilled immigration systems share a common goal – attracting talent to fill labor shortages and boost the economy – but each country’s approach has unique features. Here’s how they compare: - Job Offer Requirement: A fundamental difference is whether a job offer is required. The UK, Singapore, and (practically) New Zealand require a job offer for skilled visas (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand). Canada and Australia do not require a job offer for their flagship programs; candidates can immigrate independently based purely on points. Germany’s new Opportunity Card also does not require a job upfront (it’s a job-search visa). Pros & Cons: Requiring a job offer (UK, SG, NZ) ensures immediate employment and easier integration, but it limits access to those who secure jobs, potentially excluding high-skilled individuals who could contribute but haven’t navigated job markets yet. Systems without a job offer requirement (CA, AU, DE) allow more flexibility and attract highly qualified people proactively, though those migrants will then need to job-hunt upon arrival. - Permanent Residency vs. Temporary Visa: Canada, Australia, and New Zealand offer direct permanent residence (or a clear pathway to it) through their points systems. A successful Express Entry or SMC applicant becomes a permanent resident from day one. The UK and Singapore, however, initially grant temporary work visas (e.g., a 5-year Skilled Worker visa, a 2-3-year EP), with the option to extend and eventually apply for settlement or PR after a number of years. Germany’s Opportunity Card is temporary (12 months) – it’s more a stepping stone to a work permit, not PR. Pros & Cons: Direct PR (CA, AU, NZ) is very attractive to migrants (security and full rights) and helps those countries retain talent. Temporary visas (UK, SG) let countries adjust policy quickly and manage who transitions to PR, but some skilled workers may prefer destinations offering immediate PR. - Selection Factors: All systems consider factors like education, work experience, language ability, and age – but with different weightings. Canada and Australia have the most comprehensive points grids, rewarding a combination of factors (Canada’s CRS and FSW grid; Australia’s 65-point test). New Zealand’s new system narrows it down to essentially qualification, income, and NZ work – simplicity at the cost of flexibility. The UK’s system is binary for most factors (you either have the required job/English or you cannot apply) and uses salary as the main variable tradeable factor. Singapore’s COMPASS adds company-related criteria (diversity and local hiring), a unique twist focusing on labor market impact beyond the individual. Germany’s points focus on language, age, experience, ties – targeting youth with potential. Pros & Cons: Canada and Australia’s broad points allow many combinations to qualify, benefiting diverse profiles (e.g., a slightly older person with great language and work experience can compensate for age). This casts a wide net but can be complex. Simpler frameworks (NZ’s 6-point, UK’s 70-point checklist) are easy to understand, but might omit some merit factors (e.g., NZ doesn’t explicitly score language or age – though they impose an age limit and require English). Singapore’s and Germany’s systems incorporate labor market integration aspects (firm diversity in SG, German language in DE), which help ensure migrants fit well into the local context, though these might make it harder for some qualified people to qualify (a great candidate might miss out if they happen to share nationality with many coworkers in SG, for instance). - Pass Marks & Quotas: Canada’s CRS cut-off floats based on quotas and pool composition; there’s no fixed passing score – it’s competitive. Australia’s pass mark is fixed at 65, but actual invitation scores vary by occupation demand. New Zealand’s pass mark is fixed (6 points) with a selection cap (3,000/year currently). UK’s is fixed at 70 and not quota-limited – essentially every applicant who meets it can get a visa. Singapore’s is fixed at 40 points (COMPASS) and not explicitly quota-ed, though EPs overall are subject to government policy considerations. Germany’s Opportunity Card** likely has an annual quota (not explicitly stated in our sources, but initial plans mentioned a certain number per year), and pass mark is 6. Pros & Cons: Competitive systems (Canada, partly Australia) adjust to labor market needs dynamically but can be unpredictable for applicants – a candidate might be eligible yet never invited if the score doesn’t reach the moving target. Fixed pass mark systems (UK, SG, NZ’s new approach) offer certainty – if you meet criteria, you apply and should get approved – but they rely on careful calibration to ensure not too many or too few people qualify. Singapore manages volume through salary thresholds and the inherent difficulty of meeting all criteria, rather than a numeric cap. - Occupations in Demand vs. Broad Skills: Some countries explicitly prioritize specific occupations. Canada in 2023 introduced category-based draws for certain occupations like healthcare and trades. Australia replaced its lists with the broad CSOL of 456 jobs but still effectively filters by occupation demand via states. The UK has the Shortage Occupation List with slightly relaxed criteria for those jobs (e.g., lower salary threshold, lower fee) but even non-shortage skilled jobs can get visas if sponsored. Singapore’s bonus points for the Shortage Occupation List directly favor in-demand roles. New Zealand’s system doesn’t explicitly list occupations for SMC points (except via salary or registration which correlates to occupations), but they maintain a Green List outside SMC for key jobs (like nurses, engineers) giving immediate residence. Germany’s system doesn’t target by occupation in the points, but practically, those with in-demand skills will find it easier to secure jobs once there (and the government is expected to monitor which sectors Opportunity Card applicants come from). Pros & Cons: By prioritizing occupations (Canada’s targeted draws, SG’s SOL points), countries can fill critical shortages faster – e.g., inviting only healthcare workers helps hospitals. The downside is it may overlook other skilled applicants who could also contribute. Broad systems (like UK’s, which is employer-driven for any skilled job, or Aus/NZ where any listed skilled occupation is fair game) allow more flexibility and market-driven outcomes – employers or labor market demands ultimately determine which occupations come. Singapore’s method of awarding bonus points rather than exclusive selection strikes a balance: in-demand talents get a leg up but don’t entirely exclude others. - Ease of Navigating the System: For applicants, Canada and Australia’s processes involve more upfront work and documentation – language tests, credential assessments, and a waiting period in a pool. But once invited, PR is relatively quick (within ~6 months). The UK and Singapore’s processes are quicker to get a decision (a few weeks) once a job is secured (Skilled Worker visa: Apply from outside the UK - GOV.UK), but the challenge is securing that job and sponsor. New Zealand’s new system requires a job and then involves an Expression of Interest and potentially months of processing due to limited slots – it might take 6-12 months total to get residence after securing a job (during which one might be on a work visa). Germany’s Opportunity Card process is new – likely a few months to get the visa after meeting criteria, then one year to job hunt. Pros & Cons: Countries with straightforward employer-led processes (UK, SG) can often facilitate faster initial migration, which employers appreciate. However, migrants are more dependent on employers (tied to the specific job) and might feel less secure initially. Countries granting immediate PR (CA, AU, NZ) require more vetting and wait but give migrants full flexibility and stability once landed. - Integration Factors: Some systems explicitly include integration or retention factors: - Language: Canada and Australia strongly emphasize language (English or French) through points. New Zealand requires English but doesn’t give extra points for being above a threshold. The UK expects English B1 but doesn’t reward higher proficiency beyond that mandatory pass. Singapore’s system interestingly does not have an English test requirement for EPs (most EP candidates are degree holders often fluent in English; they rely on employer’s judgment). Germany gives points for German or English, but notably values German at B2 for full points, reflecting how important German language is for working and living there. - Age: Australia and Canada heavily favor younger applicants (Australia gives 30 points for age 25-32, and zero after 45) which is why they have an age cutoff at 45; Canada’s CRS sharply drops points after age 30 and effectively maxes at 45. New Zealand and Singapore have age cutoffs (55 for NZ, ∞ for SG EP but practical via salary) (Changes to the Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa | Immigration New Zealand), but not point allocations. The UK has no age limit or points, though younger workers often qualify more easily by being “new entrants” on salary. Germany explicitly gives 2 points for <35, aligning with preference for younger migrants likely to stay longer in the workforce. Emphasizing youth helps long-term demographic impact but can exclude older, highly experienced talent. - Local Employment/Experience: New Zealand rewards having work experience in NZ (1 point per year) to ease conversion of temporary workers to residents – a retention tool. Canada similarly has the Canadian Experience Class and gives CRS points for Canadian study/work. Australia and UK do not directly give points for local experience in their skilled independent categories (though Australian employer-sponsored or graduate visas provide alternate routes). Singapore’s COMPASS indirectly rewards companies that employ locals (C4) and diversity (C3), promoting workplace integration. - Family & Settlement: None of these points systems directly score having family in-country, except Canada’s FSW adaptability gives a few points for relatives, and Germany’s spouse point. But all allow bringing immediate family (with varying conditions). New Zealand and Australia require dependents to meet English or have to pay for classes. The UK and SG require dependents to meet health/background only, but no language requirement for them (UK dependants have no test, SG dependants aren’t separate since EP is a work pass and PR can be applied for later). This shows differences in integration approach – e.g., Aus/NZ ensure the whole family can integrate linguistically; UK/SG figure the primary’s job suffices and family can learn later or not as critical for visa. - Processing Times & Backlogs: Canada’s Express Entry is quite fast after invitation (often ~6 months), but the wait to be invited can be long or uncertain if below the cut-off. Australia’s processing for invited applicants is also ~3-9 months, but many wait in the EOI pool for a long time to get invited. The UK’s process from job offer to visa is very fast (often 3 weeks) (Skilled Worker visa: Apply from outside the UK - GOV.UK); Singapore’s EP processing is ~3-8 weeks typically, also quick. New Zealand’s new SMC might take 4-6 months for a decision, and currently they select EOIs every 2 months. Germany’s Opportunity Card might vary by consulate, but likely a few months for visa issuance (plus time to get degree recognized and language certificates). Bottom line: If speed to migrate is a priority, UK and Singapore have an edge (given a job in hand), whereas Canada/Australia require more patience but offer PR. New Zealand lies in between – you must work first (perhaps on a work visa) then get PR in a moderate timeframe. - Costs for Applicants: Immigration fees and costs differ: - Canada: Express Entry PR application fee ~CAD $1,365 (+ medical exams, etc.), relatively moderate. - Australia: Skilled visa fee ~AUD $4,000+, plus skills assessments and potential state nomination fees, making it quite expensive. - UK: Skilled Worker visa for 5 years costs ~£1,519 fee + £3,120 health surcharge, so roughly £4,600 (about USD $5,700) per person, which is high; plus employer pays sponsorship charges. But it’s pay-as-you-go (temporary visa, not PR). - Singapore: EP fees are low (around S$330 total), essentially negligible to the applicant (employers often cover it) – Singapore uses policy control, not high fees, to manage intake. - New Zealand: SMC Expression of Interest + application totals around NZD $6,500 for a single applicant, one of the higher PR costs globally. - Germany: Opportunity Card visa fee likely ~€75-100 (typical for national visas), but you have costs for translating and certifying documents, language courses, etc. Implications: High fees (UK, NZ, Aus) might deter some or ensure only serious applicants apply, while low fees (Canada, SG, Germany) make the process accessible. Employers in UK/SG cover some costs (sponsor license, etc.), whereas in Canada/Aus, the individual shoulders most costs (language tests, etc.). - Policy Flexibility and Trends: Countries adjust their systems regularly: - Canada is becoming more fine-tuned with category-based draws, showing flexibility to target priorities (like French speakers, healthcare) within the points framework. - Australia is undertaking a major overhaul to simplify and align the points with economic outcomes – likely making it more like NZ (clearer pathways for high skills) and trimming point gimmicks. - UK post-Brexit system is new (since 2021) and relatively stable; changes in 2025 are incremental (salary tweaks, compliance). But political pressure exists to possibly raise salary thresholds or limit some dependants in the future, so it might tighten or shift focus (e.g., more toward high-skilled, less on lower-paid care). - Singapore just introduced COMPASS, a big change, and will likely monitor it. They could adjust SOL occupations or thresholds depending on economic needs each year. Singapore also has other upcoming work visa refinements (e.g., a new ONE Pass for top talent). - New Zealand dramatically simplified its system; it will watch if the 6-point criteria brings the “right” migrants. They might increase the income thresholds as wages rise or tweak points if too many (or too few) qualify. Also, an election or policy change could see them either loosening the current cap or reintroducing stricter selection if needed. - Germany in 2024 embraced points for the first time; they’ll see how it works. If successful, Germany could expand points to other visa types or increase quotas. If challenges arise (like few people find jobs or integration issues), they might adjust language or support requirements. Overall, 2025 trends show targeting and quality are focal points. Countries want not just any skilled immigrants, but those who best match their labor needs and integrate well. That’s why we see moves like Canada’s targeted draws, Australia’s upcoming points revamp to favor education and English, Singapore’s holistic COMPASS, and Germany’s emphasis on language and youth. Pros and Cons Summary: - Canada: Pros: Clear PR pathway, very high chance of settlement success for those who qualify; flexible in not requiring job upfront; now targeting key skills (good for those in priority sectors). Cons: Competitive CRS system can be tough; if you’re not high-scoring, you could be in limbo; licensing for certain professions can be complex after arrival (e.g. foreign doctors/engineers still need Canadian certification). - Australia: Pros: Also offers PR, rewards well-rounded candidates; multiple visa subclasses provide options (189 independent, 190 state-nominated, etc.); actively reforming to favor future-focused skills. Cons: Rigid age cutoff at 45; lengthy EOI wait for some; expensive process; some find points system complex (many factors to juggle). - UK: Pros: Straightforward if you have a job offer; fast process; no formal education or age requirement if employer is satisfied; after 5 years can settle. Cons: Must find a sponsoring employer (can be challenging due to sponsorship bureaucracy); tied to that employer (less job flexibility initially); costs like health surcharge add burden; PR (ILR) not immediate. - Singapore: Pros: Business-friendly environment; high salaries for EP roles; fairly quick visa approvals for qualified hires; COMPASS ensures fair consideration and workforce diversity; possibility of PR later (though not guaranteed). Cons: Needs a job offer and high salary to qualify; no direct PR (EP is a work permit); criteria like diversity and local workforce support are beyond the individual’s control; family PR is restrictive until the EP holder qualifies individually for PR. - New Zealand: Pros: Now relatively simple criteria; clear route from work to residence; emphasizes recognized skills (degrees, registration) and rewards those who commit to NZ (points for local experience); smaller population means high demand in many sectors – good opportunities. Cons: Requires a job in NZ which might be hard from overseas; processing capacity is limited (capped selections initially); salaries in NZ are generally lower than in AUS/CA/US, so the 1.5x median wage threshold might be a high bar in absolute terms for some fields; geographic remoteness can be a factor for migrants.
Check your eligibility for Australian immigration using our SkillSelect Points Calculator. Quickly estimate your points based on age, education, experience, language skills, and more.
Measure the difference between required skills and your current abilities. Plan your professional development with a clear skills gap score.
Estimate your points for New Zealand's Skilled Migrant Category Resident Visa using our updated 2024 points calculator. Check your qualification, income, or registration points and add work experience to see if you meet the minimum threshold.